You found a buyer you trust completely: your son, your sister, your business partner's spouse. Selling the rental to a family member feels simple, no strangers walking through the property, no financing contingencies, no realtor commission. But a related party sale rental property transaction carries IRS rules that can quietly erase a tax loss you were counting on, or create a taxable gain years later that nobody warned you about.
At WAYG, our Coral Gables headquarters fields these calls constantly from South Florida landlords who assumed a family sale would be the easy path. It often is, financially and emotionally. But the tax code treats transactions between related parties with suspicion, and the rules under Internal Revenue Code Section 267 can change the outcome of your sale dramatically. If you own rental property in Miami-Dade County and you are considering selling to a relative, here is what actually happens on your tax return.
What Counts as a Related Party Sale Rental Property Transaction
The IRS defines "related parties" far more broadly than most people expect. Under IRC Section 267(b), related parties include:
Get our starter pack of tax guides, free.
One welcome email with our most-used guides, then a few genuinely useful ones a month. Unsubscribe anytime.
- Siblings (whether full or half blood)
- Spouses
- Ancestors (parents, grandparents)
- Lineal descendants (children, grandchildren)
- Corporations where you own more than 50% of the stock, directly or through family attribution
- Partnerships where you hold a majority interest
- Certain trusts and their beneficiaries
Notice what is absent from that list: cousins, in-laws, aunts, uncles, and nieces or nephews are not considered related parties for purposes of Section 267. A sale to your brother-in-law, for example, does not trigger the related party loss disallowance rule, even though it feels like a family transaction in every other sense.
This distinction matters enormously for South Florida business owners who structure deals through family limited partnerships or S corporations. If you own 60% of an LLC that holds rental property and you sell that property to your daughter, the attribution rules can pull her ownership and yours together in ways that surprise even sophisticated investors.
Why the IRS Cares About Family Transactions
The concern is not sentimental, it is economic. Without related party rules, a landlord could sell a depreciated rental property to a spouse for a deliberately low price, claim a large capital loss, and then have the spouse sell the property again a year later at market value, effectively manufacturing a tax loss out of thin air while keeping the asset in the family. Section 267 shuts that door.
The Related Party Loss Disallowed Rule, Explained
This is the provision that catches the most people off guard. If you sell a rental property to a related party at a loss, that loss is completely disallowed, not limited, not deferred until later, disallowed entirely for the seller.
Here is a real-world example we see often in Coral Gables and across Miami-Dade County:
Example 1: The Disallowed Loss
Maria purchased a duplex in Hialeah for $320,000 in 2015. After depreciation deductions of $58,000, her adjusted basis is $262,000. In 2026, she sells the duplex to her son for $240,000 because she wants to help him get into real estate without a big down payment.
On paper, Maria has a $22,000 loss ($262,000 basis minus $240,000 sale price). Under normal rules, that loss would offset capital gains elsewhere on her return. But because her son is a related party under Section 267(b), the entire $22,000 loss is disallowed. Maria cannot deduct one dollar of it.
The Silver Lining: The Son Gets a Special Basis Rule
The disallowed loss is not simply gone forever. The related party buyer receives a special basis rule that can offset gain if the property is later sold at a profit.
Maria's son now owns the duplex with a cost basis of $240,000 for depreciation purposes. But he also carries a "right to offset" of $22,000, the disallowed loss amount, that he can use only to reduce gain if he eventually sells the property for more than $240,000.
If he sells for $255,000 in 2029, his taxable gain calculation looks like this:
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Sale price | $255,000 |
| Son's cost basis | $240,000 |
| Realized gain before adjustment | $15,000 |
| Disallowed loss offset available | $22,000 |
| Taxable gain | $0 |
Because the offset ($22,000) exceeds the gain ($15,000), the son owes no capital gains tax on the sale. The excess $7,000 simply disappears, it cannot create a deductible loss for him either. This dual basis system is unique to related party transactions and trips up even experienced real estate investors across South Florida.
Gifted or Bargain-Sale Transactions: A Different Trap
Many families do not sell at fair market value at all, they sell at a "friends and family" discount intending part of the transaction as a gift. This creates a separate set of complications involving gift tax exposure and basis bifurcation.
Example 2: The Bargain Sale
Robert owns a rental condo in Coral Gables with a fair market value of $410,000 and an adjusted basis of $295,000. He sells it to his daughter for $300,000, well below market value, intending the discount as a financial gift.
The IRS treats this as a part-sale, part-gift transaction. For gift tax purposes, Robert has made a gift of $110,000 ($410,000 fair market value minus $300,000 sale price), which eats into his lifetime gift and estate tax exemption and requires a gift tax return (Form 709) if it exceeds the annual exclusion amount.
For income tax purposes, Robert's gain is calculated using the sale price against his basis: $300,000 minus $295,000 equals a $5,000 taxable gain, small, but not zero. His daughter's basis depends on whether she later sells at a gain or loss, a dual basis rule similar to the disallowed loss scenario, but layered with gift tax basis carryover rules from IRC Section 1015.
Depreciation Recapture Does Not Disappear
Even in a related party loss disallowance scenario, depreciation recapture under Section 1250 can still apply to the portion of the sale that represents a gain, or in some structured transactions, create unexpected ordinary income. Miami-area entrepreneurs who have aggressively depreciated rental property using cost segregation studies need to model this carefully before finalizing a family sale, because recapture is taxed at a rate up to 25%, separate from the capital gains treatment on the rest of the transaction.
Example 3: Full Recapture Exposure
David owns a rental house in Miami Lakes purchased for $280,000 with $70,000 in accumulated depreciation, giving him a basis of $210,000. He sells it to his niece for $265,000. Because a niece is not a related party under Section 267(b), this sale is NOT subject to the loss disallowance rule, but David still has a real, taxable gain.
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Sale price | $265,000 |
| Adjusted basis | $210,000 |
| Total gain | $55,000 |
| Unrecaptured Section 1250 gain (taxed up to 25%) | $55,000 |
| Tax at 25% recapture rate | $13,750 |
David owes $13,750 in federal tax on the depreciation recapture portion alone, even though he sold the property to a relative at what felt like a modest, below-market price. This example illustrates why confirming whether your buyer actually qualifies as a related party under the tax code, rather than assuming based on family closeness, changes the entire tax outcome.
Related Party Sales Table: Who Triggers the Rule
| Relationship to Seller | Related Party Under Section 267? | Loss Disallowance Applies? |
|---|---|---|
| Spouse | Yes | Yes |
| Child or grandchild | Yes | Yes |
| Parent or grandparent | Yes | Yes |
| Sibling (full or half) | Yes | Yes |
| Niece or nephew | No | No |
| Aunt or uncle | No | No |
| Cousin | No | No |
| In-law (not spouse) | No | No |
| Corporation you control (over 50%) | Yes | Yes |
| Partnership you control (majority) | Yes | Yes |
Structuring a Family Rental Sale the Right Way
If you are planning a related party sale rental property transaction in South Florida, these steps reduce surprises:
- Get a qualified appraisal before setting the price. This establishes fair market value and protects both parties if the IRS questions the transaction later.
- Decide whether a gift component is intended. If so, document it clearly and file Form 709 if the gifted amount exceeds the annual exclusion.
- Calculate your adjusted basis precisely, including all depreciation taken, before estimating gain or loss.
- Model the buyer's future basis and offset rights, especially if a loss will be disallowed on your side.
- Account for depreciation recapture separately from capital gain or loss, since it is taxed at a different rate.
- Put the transaction in writing with a proper deed, closing statement, and, ideally, a promissory note if any portion is financed, to avoid the IRS recharacterizing the deal as a disguised gift.
- Consult a tax professional before closing, not after, since basis elections and structuring choices often cannot be undone once the deed records.
Our team regularly helps Miami-area entrepreneurs model these scenarios using our business tax strategy planning process before any paperwork is signed, because the tax outcome often depends on decisions made weeks or months before closing.
How This Fits Into Your Broader Tax Picture
A related party rental sale rarely happens in isolation. It typically intersects with estate planning, entity structuring, and sometimes multi-year income smoothing strategies, especially for South Florida business owners who hold several properties inside LLCs or family partnerships. If you are running rental activity through a business entity, our small business bookkeeping services keep your basis records and depreciation schedules accurate so that when a sale does happen, the numbers are ready rather than reconstructed under pressure.
For clients juggling multiple properties and ongoing reporting obligations, our managed accounting service maintains clean books year-round, which becomes critical when calculating adjusted basis on a property you have owned for a decade or more. And if you want ongoing access to a tax professional who understands related party rules without hiring a full-time CFO, our virtual CPA services give South Florida landlords that level of support on a flexible basis.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can I ever deduct a loss on a related party sale rental property transaction? A: No, not on your own return. The loss is fully disallowed under Section 267, regardless of how small or large it is. However, the related party buyer can potentially use that disallowed amount to offset gain if they later sell the property at a profit above their purchase price.
Q: Does selling to my cousin trigger the related party loss disallowance rule? A: No. Cousins, nieces, nephews, aunts, uncles, and most in-laws are not considered related parties under IRC Section 267(b). A loss on a sale to a cousin is generally deductible like any arm's length transaction, though the IRS can still scrutinize the price if it looks artificially low.
Q: What is the most common mistake South Florida landlords make in family property sales? A: Assuming any sale to a relative automatically counts as a gift or automatically avoids taxes. In reality, bargain sales create a split transaction with both gift tax and income tax consequences, and even sales at full market value to non-related family members like nieces or nephews still generate taxable gain and depreciation recapture.
Q: Do I need a formal appraisal before selling a rental property to a family member in Miami-Dade County? A: Yes, strongly recommended. An independent appraisal establishes fair market value, which protects you if the IRS later questions whether the sale price was artificially low to disguise a gift or artificially high to shift income. It also supports your basis calculations for depreciation recapture and gain reporting.
Q: How does depreciation recapture work when selling a rental to a family member? A: Depreciation recapture under Section 1250 applies regardless of whether the buyer is a related party, taxed at rates up to 25% on the recaptured portion of your gain. This tax exists separately from the capital gain or loss calculation and cannot be avoided simply because the buyer is family.
Q: Should I use an installment sale when selling a rental property to my child? A: Installment sales can spread out gain recognition and ease the financial burden on a family buyer, but special related party rules under Section 453(e) can accelerate gain recognition if the buyer resells the property within two years. This structure requires careful planning before you finalize terms.
Final Thoughts on Related Party Sales
Selling a rental property to a family member can be one of the most rewarding financial decisions you make, helping a child build equity or keeping an asset in the family for another generation. But a related party sale rental property transaction operates under different rules than a sale to a stranger, and the related party loss disallowed provision in particular can turn an expected tax benefit into nothing at all.
Before you sign anything, get the numbers modeled by someone who understands both the Section 267 rules and your specific depreciation history. Our Coral Gables team works with South Florida landlords and entrepreneurs every week on exactly these transactions, and a short strategy session now can prevent a costly surprise at filing time. Schedule a consultation with WAYG today, or request a quote to see how proper planning protects your next family property sale.